|
The New York Times
TAYBEH, West Bank — Jack Massis, 51, a grocer
here in this last entirely Christian village in the West
Bank, speaks matter-of-factly about how two of his
teenage sons were beaten with clubs last month.
They had argued with members of a Muslim family that had
moved three years ago to the edge of Taybeh, a
picturesque village in the hills near Ramallah with a
dwindling population of 1,300. Mr. Massis’ sons had used
a road that ran along the newcomers’ property, which the
newcomers insisted was private. The sons spent the night
in the hospital, and five members of the Muslim family
spent a few days in jail.
In the year since Hamas came to power, some of
the fears of a newly Islamist cast to Palestinian
society are being borne out. Christians have begun
quietly complaining that local disagreements quickly
take on a sectarian flavor. And reports of beatings and
property damage by Muslims have grown.
In one of the most serious cases, Palestinian
gunmen in September set the Y.M.C.A. building on fire in
the West Bank city of Qalqilya, where Hamas members hold
all 15 local council seats. Muslim figures in the city
had previously accused the Y.M.C.A. of engaging in
missionary activity and warned it to close down.
But few point directly at Hamas, looking instead
to the overall stresses on Palestinian society and its
increasing thuggishness. As Mr. Massis said of his sons’
beatings, “There are such problems every day.”
While it is hard to gauge what role intimidation
and nationalist sensibilities play, there is widespread
denial of any official persecution. Some prominent
Christians praise the Hamas leadership for allowing the
Christian community its religious freedom and conducting
itself in a more honorable fashion than the previous
government did.
“The Christians are happier now, with Hamas, than
in the period before,” said Jeries Khoury, the Christian
director of Al Liqa, an institute for religious studies.
“They are respected. Of course people are still leaving,
but Hamas, or ‘the Muslims,’ are the last reason for
that.”
Claudette Habesch, secretary general of Caritas
Jerusalem, a branch of the international Catholic relief
organization, said that Ismail Haniya, the Palestinian
prime minister from Hamas, “is a very civilized man.”
She added, “He has gained a lot of respect from the
community at large.”
To explain their troubles, many Palestinians
point to the economic hardship and unemployment caused
by the cutoff of outside aid and Israeli security
measures that bar most Palestinians from working inside
Israel; the disruptions from internal Palestinian
instability and lawlessness; and in some cases, corrupt
elements connected with the secular Fatah party that
dominated the Palestinian Authority for the decade
before 2006.
Other factors make Christians particularly
vulnerable. In the Palestinian Authority areas of the
West Bank and Gaza Strip, their numbers are now down to
55,000 or 60,000, or 1.7 percent of the Palestinian
population. Those who remain must struggle to preserve
their weakened communities and lands from encroachment
by stronger parties. And Christians lack the protection
other Palestinians claim from large clans or their own
militias.
The Christians’ problems are writ large in
Bethlehem, where most Palestinian Christians live. Fifty
years ago, its population was 90 percent Christian; that
has fallen, because of emigration and relatively low
birth rates, to just 35 percent.
There, land theft — a problem in many parts of
Palestinian territory — is particularly rife, in part
because there is no proper registration of land. Many
land owners have lived abroad for decades, and some are
now selling off plots against the will of relatives who
stayed behind, or vice versa.
The mayor, a Christian leftist named Victor
Batarseh, said the “land-stealing mafia” used judges and
lawyers to shift titles. But he added that it was not an
anti-Christian campaign. “There are also Christians who
help the mafia,” he said. Mr. Batarseh is waiting for
Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president from Fatah, to
issue a decree for the registration of Bethlehem’s land,
as a first step toward solving the problem.
Samir Qumsieh, a Christian advocate and manager
of Bethlehem’s private Al Mahed, or Nativity, television
station, said he had repeatedly appealed to Mr. Abbas,
and his predecessor, Yasir Arafat, to stop the land
thefts.
Mr. Qumsieh, a controversial figure in his
community, has spoken out widely in the Western news
media about what he calls the “dirty mafia.” Two
firebombs were thrown in his yard last August, and
though no one was hurt he is now extremely cautious
about how he will be quoted. But he underlined that
there was no “official persecution,” and that Hamas had
not taken any land.
Other Bethlehem Palestinians say the problem with
land theft has been going on since 1994, when the
Palestinian Authority was established. They say it
involves local figures closely connected with Fatah. A
spokesman for the Palestinian Authority police in
Bethlehem said that three Muslims were under
investigation on suspicion of land theft, and dismissed
talk of Fatah involvement as “just rumors.”
Land has become an issue in Taybeh, too. Up to
three-quarters of the village lands are owned by exiles,
said the Rev .Raed Abusahlia, an energetic parish priest
for the Latin Patriarchate, an arm of the Latin Rite
Roman Catholic Church in the Holy Land. No one is left
to look after it, and the exiles’ descendents want to
sell.
Father Raed considers living in the Holy Land a
vocation, and sees preserving Taybeh’s land as his “next
battle,” though buying it all would cost millions of
dollars that the village does not have, he said.
“We are not fanatic, but this is the only
entirely Christian village left,” he said, adding,
“Those who leave weaken those who stay.”
As for Mr. Massis, after his sons were discharged
and their assailants got out of jail, a clan head from
Hebron paid a visit, and symbolic compensation was paid.
“The problem was settled,” Mr. Massis said.
The residents of Taybeh are now trying to buy the
Hebron family out. “It’s not because they are Muslims,”
Mr. Massis insisted. “It’s because they are
troublemakers.”
Nevertheless, he revealed a degree of ambivalence
about the Palestinian Christians’ long-term prospects in
the area. “Their children call us atheists,” he said.
“The illiterates who support Hamas look at us as
foreigners, not Palestinians. Many of them look at us
this way.”
|