As an elder within the
Palestinian community, I am
proud to address you today -
you who purport to be
interested in a just peace
for this country. At the
outset, however, I must warn
you that there has been much
criticism levelled against
this conference - and
justifiably so.
Similar previous pursuits
for a solution to the
conflict between
Palestinians and the Zionist
movement have yielded only
negative results that
further complicate the
situation and that have
exposed the Palestinians and
the Israelis to great
ethical and political
pressures. The goal has
always been to force the
Palestinians and the
Israelis to reconcile their
conflicting claims by
neglecting the very basis of
the rights of the two
parties as prescribed by the
United Nations. Whatever the
nature of the intent behind
the various initiatives,
pressure cannot lead to
success. On the contrary,
the methods for so-called
negotiations in the past
have led to increasing
instability and war. It is
ironic that, after all these
years, neither of the
conflicting parties has been
able to claim victory.
Neither party has brought to
fruition its aspirations.
Being of “a certain age,” I
have spent many long years
witnessing this drama unfold
and being attentive to the
roles that various external
players have assumed. And
unfortunately, it has been
impossible to observe any
meaningful interpretation of
the conflict, much less a
workable solution. After
sixty years, I must admit
that I fail to detect any
sense of logic between the
legitimacy provided by the
United Nations through the
Partition Plan and the fait
accompli that we experience
in Palestine at the moment.
To add insult to injury, the
present situation,
especially since 1967, is
considered by Israel and the
United States to be the
benchmark and starting point
for negotiations on the
future of the Occupied
Territories. My question is:
How can an “illegitimate”
fait accompli be forced to
become “legitimate” with the
blessing of the United
Nations?
Given the sustained
opposition to the Israeli
occupation by the
established Palestinian
national movement in the
Occupied Territories and the
intransigence of Israel in
sustaining its occupation,
the conflict has become very
dangerous and genuinely
worrisome for the
international community. As
a matter of fact, the impact
of the conflict has already
crossed the borders of
Palestine, inviting more
external players to its
locus. Despite the past
failures of the United
Nations - especially the
failure to implement General
Assembly resolutions 181 and
194 and Security Council
resolutions 242 and 338,
among others - its help is
needed now more than ever.
The United Nations is
generally seen as an honest
broker that can initiate a
meaningful peace process.
Chapter seven of the Charter
is still at hand and can be
a base for a more effective
role.
The problem of implementing
UN resolutions, however, and
the absence of consistency
among them is due to the
absurd administration of the
five permanent members of
the Security Council who aim
to use the channels of the
UN to impose their interests
and policies. Their veto
“privileges” allow them to
block the passing or
implementation of any
resolution. Its para-legal
status has given the United
States a virtual monopoly
over the
Palestinian-Israeli-conflict
issue and has marginalized
the roles of the other
members. One might even say
that the “will” of the
United Nations has become
hostage to the whims of the
Security Council’s permanent
members. But the fact
remains: the United States
continues to be the major
external player in the
conflict.
Since 1967, continuous
efforts have been made to
find a solution to the
conflict. There have been
many international envoys,
some of whom were sent by
the secretary general of the
United Nations, others by
superpowers, and still
others by well-intentioned
leaders of the world. To the
misfortune of the
conflicting parties, the
missions were not taken
seriously by the United
States. While UN resolutions
are, by fiat, in deep
freeze, and previous
failures are ignored, the US
call to convene this “new”
international conference in
Annapolis simply adds
another scene to this
farcical drama.
Is the United States willing
and able to recognize the
inalienable rights of the
Palestinians as described in
the UN Charter and clearly
stated in UN resolutions
related to the conflict? Is
the United States ready to
recognize that the Jewish
settlements in the Occupied
Palestinian Territories are
illegal? Is it ready to
respect the will of the
Palestinians, as
demonstrated by the recent
elections for their
legislative council in
2005/2006, and stop the
unjust “collective
punishment” that has been
forced on Gaza and the West
Bank? Furthermore, is the
United States willing to
press Israel to withdraw to
the June 4, 1967 borders and
to denounce Israel’s
brutality against the
Palestinians?
These same questions have
been asked by Palestinians
time and again over the
years. And time and again,
they are ignored. The
situation grows worse. Land
continues to be confiscated.
Refugees still wait to
return to their homes. Why
then is yet another
conference being convened in
an atmosphere that is
shrouded in scepticism and
ambiguity? The means to a
solution already exists if
one is willing to respect
and observe the charters of
human and political rights.
To continue to turn a blind
eye to this reality is to
prolong the agony of the
Palestinians, the Israelis,
and the international
community.
Conference participants take
note:This conference will
only serve to perpetuate the
myth that blindness and
ignorance can lead to peace.
Enough is enough!