








Jerusalem-forum@wanadoo.jo

|
|
Remembering 1948 and looking to the future
Ali Abunimah, The Electronic Intifada, 13 May 2008

Twenty-six-year-old Jamila Merhi was forced from her family's home in Akbara village near Safad, Palestine in 1948. Now, 86, she lives in the Shatila refugee camp in Beirut, Lebanon and still holds onto a copy of her family's deed for their land in Palestine. (Matthew Cassel)
This
month
Israel
marks
the 60th
anniversary
of its
founding.
But
amidst
the
festivities
including
visits
by
international
celebrities
and
politicians
there is
deep
unease
--
Israel
has
skeletons
in its
closet
that it
has
tried
hard to
hide,
and
anxieties
about an
uncertain
future
which
make
many
Israelis
question
whether
the
state
will
celebrate
an 80th
birthday.
Official
Israel
remains
in
complete
denial
that the
birth it
celebrates
is
inextricably
linked
with the
near
destruction
of the
vibrant
Palestinian
culture
and
society
that had
existed
until
then.
It's not
an
unfamiliar
dilemma
for
settler
states.
The
United
States,
where I
live,
has
found
that
even the
passage
of
centuries
cannot
absolve
a nation
from
confronting
the
crimes
committed
at its
founding.
As the
noted
Israeli
historian
and
staunch
Zionist
Benny
Morris
put it
in 2004,
"a
Jewish
state
would
not have
come
into
being
without
the
uprooting
of
700,000
Palestinians.
Therefore
it was
necessary
to
uproot
them."
He went
on,
"there
are
circumstances
in
history
that
justify
ethnic
cleansing."
But if
one is
not
prepared
to
openly
justify
ethnic
cleansing,
there's
only two
real
options:
to deny
history
and take
comfort
in an
airbrushed
story
that
paints
Israelis
as
brave,
divinely
inspired
pioneers
in a
desert
devoid
of
indigenous
people
and
beset by
external
enemies,
or to
own up
to the
consequences
and
support
the
enormous
redress
needed
to bring
justice
and
peace.
Just
before
Israel's
founding,
Palestinians
of all
religions
made up
two
thirds
of the
settled
population
of
historic
Palestine,
while
Jewish
immigrants,
recently
arrived
from
Europe,
made up
most of
the
rest.
Among
those
uprooted
was my
mother,
then
nine
years
old. Now
living
in
Amman,
she
remembers
a happy
childhood
in her
native
Jerusalem
neighborhood
of Lifta.
My
grandfather
owned
several
buildings
and many
of his
tenants
were
Jews,
including
the
family
who
rented
the
downstairs
apartment
in their
house.
Early in
1948 --
before
any Arab
states'
armies
got
involved
-- she
and her
entire
family,
indeed
all the
inhabitants
of
several
neighboring
West
Jerusalem
areas,
were
forced
out by
Zionist
militias.
On 7
February
that
year,
Israel's
founding
prime
minister,
David
Ben-Gurion
told
members
of his
party,
"From
your
entry
into
Jerusalem,
through
Lifta-Romema,
through
Mahane
Yehuda,
through
King
George
Street
and Mea
Shearim
-- there
are no
strangers
[i.e.
Arabs].
One
hundred
percent
Jews."
So it
was that
the
Palestinians
became
"strangers"
in the
land of
their
birth.
Since
that
time
millions
of
refugees
and
their
descendants
who lost
their
homes,
farms,
groves,
livestock,
factories,
stores,
tools,
automobiles,
bank
accounts,
art
work,
insurance
policies,
furniture
and
every
other
possession
have
lived in
exile,
many in
squalid
refugee
camps
maintained
by
Israel
and Arab
states.
Over 80
percent
of the
Palestinians
now
besieged
and
starved
in the
Gaza
Strip
are
refugees
from
towns
now in
Israel.
But what
Palestinians
could
never be
forced
to part
with --
and this
we do
celebrate
-- is
our
attachment
to our
homeland
and the
determination
to see
justice
done.
Palestinians
all over
the
world
are
commemorating
the
start of
our
ongoing
tragedy,
but we
are also
looking
forward.
We are
at an
important
turning
point,
where
two
things
are
happening
at once.
First,
despite
ritual
declarations
of
international
support,
the
prospect
of a
two-state
solution
has all
but
disappeared
as
Palestinians
in the
West
Bank and
Gaza
Strip
are
caged
into
walled
reservations
by
growing
Israeli
settlements
and
settler-only
roads --
a
situation
that
resembles
the
bantustans
of
apartheid
South
Africa.
Second,
despite
Israel's
efforts
to keep
Palestinians
in
check,
the
Palestinian
population
living
under
Israeli
rule is
about to
exceed
the five
million
Israeli
Jews.
Today
there
are 3.5
million
Palestinians
in the
West
Bank and
Gaza
Strip,
and
another
1.5
million
Palestinians
who are
nominally
citizens
of
Israel.
Sometimes
called
"Israeli
Arabs,"
Palestinians
in
Israel
are
increasingly
restive
about
their
second
class
status
in a
Jewish
state
that
regards
them as
a
hostile
fifth
column.
While
Palestinians
in
Israel
call for
equal
rights
in a
state of
all its
citizens,
some
Israeli
Jewish
politicians
threaten
them
with
expulsion
to the
West
Bank,
Gaza
Strip or
beyond.
Official
projections
show
that by
2025,
Palestinians,
due to
their
much
higher
birth
rate,
will
exceed
Israeli
Jews in
the
country
by two
million
and
though
few in
the
international
community
have
woken up
to this
reality,
a
surgical
separation
between
these
populations
is
impossible.
Israeli
leaders
understand
what
they are
up
against;
Prime
Minister
Ehud
Olmert
said
last
November:
"If the
day
comes
when the
two-state
solution
collapses,
and we
face a
South
African-style
struggle
for
equal
voting
rights,
then, as
soon as
that
happens,
the
State of
Israel
is
finished."
This
struggle
has
already
begun as
more and
more
Palestinians,
recognizing
that
statehood
is
unrealistic,
debate
and
adopt
the
one-state
solution,
offering
Israelis
and
Palestinians
equal
rights
in the
land
they
share.
Last
year, I
was part
of a
group of
Palestinians,
Israelis
and
others
who
published
the "One
State
Declaration."
Inspired
partly
by South
Africa's
Freedom
Charter,
we set
out
principles
for a
common
future
in a
single
democratic
state.
Most
Israelis,
unsurprisingly,
recoil
at
comparisons
with
apartheid
South
Africa.
The good
news for
them is
that the
end of
apartheid
did not
bring
about
the
disaster
many
feared.
Rather,
it was a
new dawn
for all
the
people
of the
country.
Co-founder
of The
Electronic
Intifada,
Ali
Abunimah
is
author
of
One
Country:
A Bold
Proposal
to End
the
Israeli-Palestinian
Impasse
(Metropolitan
Books,
2006). A
version
of this
essay
was
originally
published
by
The
Sydney
Morning
Herald.
|