








Jerusalem-forum@wanadoo.jo

|
|
The ANZAC-Palestine connection
Sonja Karkar, The Electronic Intifada, 7 May 2008

Australian graves in Deir al-Balah in the Gaza Strip, 2007. (Dr. Richard Middleton)
"ANZACS
BACK
AGAIN"
was the
front-page
headline
of
Jerusalem's
Palestine
Post
on 13
February
1940.
The
ANZAC
reputation
for
courage
and
daring
was
legendary
after
their
victory
at
Beersheba
in 1917.
That was
the
Palestine
Campaign
that saw
the
celebrated
charge
of the
4th
Light
Horse
Brigade
on the
unsuspecting
Turks.
It was a
battle
that
turned
the tide
of that
campaign
and led
to the
subsequent
end of
Ottoman
rule in
Palestine.
During
World
War II,
Palestine
was
under a
British
Mandate
and
Australian
and New
Zealand
soldiers
were
back
helping
the
British
army to
stop the
Germans
from
capturing
Egypt
and the
Suez
Canal.
They
fought
alongside
several
Palestinian
brigades
enlisted
into the
British
Army
under
The
Palestine
Regiment.
That
decisive
offensive
took
place in
1942 at
al-Alamein,
Egypt,
the
first
allied
land
victory
of the
war.
Tragically,
more
than
2,000
ANZACS
from
both
campaigns
would
never
see
Australia
or New
Zealand
again.
Over 600
lie in
unknown
graves
with
Muslim
and
Christian
Arabs
and Jews
who also
died
trying
to
defeat
the
German
army.
Other
ANZACS
are
buried
in war
cemeteries
throughout
Palestine,
two of
which
can be
found in
Gaza --
one
beautifully
cared
for in
the
Palestinian
town of
Deir al-Balah,
and the
other in
Gaza
City.
The
Beersheba
Commonwealth
War
Cemetery
has
graves
of some
175
Australian
soldiers
and lies
on the
edge of
today's
sprawling
commercial
city
that
Israel
has
renamed
Be'er
Sheva.
Our
soldiers
knew it
as
Beersheba
with a
largely
Palestinian
population.
The
New York
Times
of 1
November
1917
described
Beersheba
as an
"ancient
Palestine
city,
having
much
strategic
value,"
and
during
the
British
Mandate,
it
remained
an
administrative
center
providing
work and
services
for some
4,000
Palestinians
who
lived in
the
area.
The next
time
Beersheba
became a
battleground
was in
1948,
when the
army of
the
newly-created
Israel
captured
the city
and
terrorized
its
Palestinian
inhabitants
into
fleeing.
It was
never
intended
to
become
part of
Israel
under
the 1947
UN
Partition
Plan,
but like
in other
parts of
Palestine,
the
Palestinians
were
never
allowed
to
return
to their
homes.
In an
effort
to
conflate
Australia's
Palestine
Campaign
with
Israel,
the
Pratt
Foundation
in
Australia,
which
contributes
heavily
towards
Israeli
causes,
commissioned
a statue
for the
new
theme
park
that it
has set
up in
memory
of the
Australian
soldiers
in
Beersheba.
That was
almost a
year
ago. A
statement
made
last
month by
Australian
Veteran
Affairs
Minister
Alan
Griffin,
said
that the
Park of
the
Australian
Soldier
was a
gift to
the
people
of Be'er
Sheva,
but for
years
the
Israelis
living
there
were
ignorant
of the
site's
significance
and
willfully
neglectful
of its
heritage.
Earlier
this
year,
the
Australian
government
was
forced
to order
an
investigation
after
the
precious
water
wells,
which
the
Australian
soldiers
had so
bravely
fought
to
secure,
were
found to
be in a
shocking
state of
disrepair
and a
virtual
rubbish
tip.
Since
then,
the
embarrassment
for
Israeli
officials
over the
neglect
of this
historic
site has
passed.
The
statue
was
unveiled
in
Beersheba
on 28
April to
commemorate
what
many
regard
as the
most
significant
victory
of
Australian
military
history
and
Australia's
Governor-General
was in
Israel
-- a
first
for our
head of
state --
along
with
other
international
dignitaries
for the
ceremony.
In
contrast,
Australia's
first
Jewish
Governor-General
Sir
Isaac
Isaacs
vigorously
questioned
the
legitimacy
of
Zionism
(the
founding
ideology
of
Israel),
describing
it as "a
monstrous
historical
crime
and
curse."
He did
not live
to see
the
state of
Israel,
but it
is
unlikely
that he
would
have
associated
himself
with it,
particularly
in light
of its
nefarious
deeds
over the
last 60
years.
Gaza has
particularly
suffered
because
of
Israel.
Subjected
for two
years to
an
increasingly
punitive
siege,
1.5
million
starving
Palestinians
are
barely
50
kilometers
away
from the
commemorations
in
Beersheba.
Their
extreme
humanitarian
need
cries
out for
attention.
They
should
not be
ignored
and
neither
should
their
history.
Some of
the
heaviest
fighting
took
place in
Gaza
during
the
Palestine
Campaign
when
ANZACS
and
Palestinian
soldiers
fought
the
Turks to
free
Palestine
from
Ottoman
rule.
Now, the
Palestinians
are
prisoners
of
Israel
-- not
only in
Gaza,
but in
the West
Bank,
including
East
Jerusalem.
The
Governor-General
ought to
have
paid his
respects
to the
ANZACS
resting
in Gazan
graves,
but it
is
unlikely
that
Israel
would
have
given
him a
permit
for free
passage
in any
case.
The
much-publicized
ANZAC-Israel
connection
would
appear
then to
be more
about
fudging
history
than
honoring
it.
While
most
Australians
would
see the
statue
and park
for the
fallen
ANZACS
as a
tribute
to their
soldiers
fighting
and
dying
for King
and
Country,
editor
Dan
Goldberg
of
Rhapsody,
a
bi-monthly
insert
in
The
Australian
Jewish
News,
sees it
as "a
permanent
memorial
to those
who died
in
battle
for the
Jewish
state."
This is
a
disturbing
and
historically
incorrect
remark,
since
the
battle
for
Beersheba
occurred
31 years
before
the
state of
Israel
even
came
into
being or
was
created
in
Palestine
for that
matter.
In fact,
the
Balfour
Declaration
of 1917,
which
sought
British
support
for a
Jewish
homeland
in
Palestine,
was
still
being
debated
by the
British
War
Cabinet
when
Beersheba
was
captured.
In the
following
decades,
the
British
denied
that a
Jewish
state
had been
intended
-- only
a
"national
home" --
and
insisted
that a
clause
be
inserted
stating
that
"nothing
shall be
done
which
may
prejudice
the
civil
and
religious
rights
of
existing
non-Jewish
communities
in
Palestine,"
which in
itself
was
insulting
to the
Palestinians
who made
up 92
percent
of the
population.
It was
not
until
1947
that the
United
Nations
member
countries,
amongst
them
Australia,
unequally
divided
Palestine
with the
stroke
of a pen
and
created
Israel
without
consulting
the
Palestinians
who had
lived
rich and
productive
lives in
the
cities,
towns
and
villages
under
the
Ottomans
and
later
the
British.
Last
month,
Palestinians
could
only
watch in
despair
as the
remembrances
took
place
and the
historical
connection
between
Australia
and
Palestine
was
usurped
by a
state
that did
not
exist
when
Australian
soldiers
fought
there
for the
British
Empire.
War
memorials
everywhere
show
Palestine
etched
in
stone.
Graves
in Gaza
honor
our
soldiers.
But even
more
telling,
are the
four
million
Palestinians
who live
in that
land
under
Israel's
brutal
occupation
and
siege
and the
7.2
million
refugees
who are
waiting
to
return
home.
They
will not
forget.
It will
take
more
than
Governor-Generals
and
statues
to
expunge
the
history
and
memories
of the
ANZAC-Palestine
connection,
try as
Israel
might.
Sonja
Karkar
is the
founder
and
president
of Women
for
Palestine
and one
of the
founders
and
co-conveners
of
Australians
for
Palestine
in
Melbourne,
Australia.
|