|
Editorial Reviews
From Publishers Weekly
In 2000, Pearlman, a Jewish doctoral student
in
Middle East
politics and longtime human rights activist, spent six months
living and studying in the West Bank. Her book grows out of
her sojourn and "provide[s] a window into the human dimension
of their struggle" by letting the Palestinians speak for
themselves. Think of it as Studs Terkel goes to the Middle
East-except that only one side in the conflict gets to speak.
The first thing that emerges from these interviews is that the
Palestinians have suffered a great deal-if someone hasn't been
hurt, jailed or degraded by the Israeli occupation, they know
someone who has. "The army just opens fire whenever it wants
to," says Mahmoud, whose house was razed by the Israeli army.
But while Pearlman says her aim is to gain a deeper
understanding of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, some
readers will come away only with despair, a sense that the
conflict will never be settled. One Palestinian after another
here shows an inability to see any legitimacy in the Israeli
side, or to support an end to the current intifada or any
attempts at peace-the moribund
Oslo peace
process is seen as a sellout. And when Pearlman fails to
question such statements as that
Israel
has failed to comply with any U.N. resolution since 1948, many
readers may despair regarding Pearlman as well.
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From
Booklist
After the peace process in the Middle East broke down in 2000,
the author, "a Jewish girl from
Nebraska," was moved to visit
Israel and speak to ordinary Palestinians living in the middle
of the second Intifada (mass uprising). She spoke with
doctors and educators, journalists and businessmen, homeowners
and students, assembling a collage of memory and emotion. Each
interview is preceded by a lengthy introduction that supplies
historical and social contexts. Pearlman's own perspective, as
a...
read
more
Book Description
When the occupied territories
exploded following the collapse of the Camp David talks and
Ariel Sharon's inflammatory visit to the Al-Aqsa Mosque in
Jerusalem, Wendy Pearlman, a young Jewish woman from Nebraska,
immersed herself amongst ordinary Palestinians and, a la Studs
Terkel, recorded their lives. A remarkable oral narrative
emerges from the school principals, professors, TV reporters,
school kids, mothers, doctors, engineers, filmmakers, shop
owners, victims of shellings and forced house removals that
spoke to her: "The personal stories and heartfelt reflections
that I encountered did not expose a hatred of Jews or a
yearning to push Israelis into the sea. Rather, they painted a
portrait of a people who longed for precisely that which had
inspired the first Israelis: the chance to be citizens in a
country of their own." Containing over thirty searing oral
testimonies, this is one of the first books to tell the
Palestinian story from the point of view of Palestinians
living in the occupied territories.
See
all editorial reviews...
Spotlight Reviews
(What's this?)
Write an online review
and share your thoughts with other customers.
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
A remarkable and illuminating book, August 9, 2003
|
|
Reviewer: A reader from Dana Point, California,
United States |
Thanks to Wendy Pearlman, now readers of this excellent and
illuminating book can better understand the feelings and
aspirations of Palestinians living under the Israeli
occupation since 1967.
This book is must reading for all young and old Palestinians
living outside the occupied territories, lest they forget the
sufferring of their people. It is also a must reading for
American citizens in the hope that they can influence, and
perhaps convince, Congress and the Administration that true
peace for both sides of the conflict can be achieved only by
ending this inhumane occupation. |